Here's how the two compare on what each company publishes, with prices checked Oct 25, 2026.
Heads up: some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes what we recommend. Learn more.
| Aloe Care Health | Medical Guardian | |
|---|---|---|
| Devices we track | 3 | 3 |
| Lowest monthly price | $39.99/mo (Aloe Care Essentials) | $27.95/mo (Medical Guardian MGHome Landline) |
| Lowest 3-year cost with fall detection | $1769.63 (Aloe Care Mobile Companion 2) | $1006.20+ (Medical Guardian MGHome Landline) |
| Device fee | $149.99 to $349.99 | Not stated |
| Fall detection | Included on some devices, extra on others | Extra monthly add-on |
| Works away from home | Yes, on mobile devices | Yes, on mobile devices |
| Smartwatch option | No | No |
| Month to month, no minimum term | Not stated | Yes |
| Cancelling | 30-day money-back guarantee; the terms behind it and any minimum term are not on the page. | No long-term contract and no activation fee; it issues pro-rated refunds for unused service, but a footnote says cancellation fees may apply. |
| See Aloe Care Health | See Medical Guardian |
Aloe Care Health · At home
Cancelling: 30-day money-back guarantee; the terms behind it and any minimum term are not on the page.Not published; checked Oct 25, 2026src
Aloe Care Health · At home
Cancelling: 30-day money-back guarantee; the terms behind it and any minimum term are not on the page.Not published; checked Oct 25, 2026src
Aloe Care Health · Home and away
Cancelling: 30-day money-back guarantee; the terms behind it and any minimum term are not on the page.Not published; checked Oct 25, 2026src
Medical Guardian · Home and away
Cancelling: No long-term contract and no activation fee; it issues pro-rated refunds for unused service, but a footnote says cancellation fees may apply.sources differ
Medical Guardian · At home
Cancelling: No long-term contract and no activation fee; it issues pro-rated refunds for unused service, but a footnote says cancellation fees may apply.sources differ
Medical Guardian · At home
Cancelling: No long-term contract and no activation fee; it issues pro-rated refunds for unused service, but a footnote says cancellation fees may apply.sources differ
See our picks in the best medical alert systems, or rank every device by three-year cost.
