Bay Alarm Medical vs Medical Guardian

Here's how the two compare on what each company publishes, with prices checked Oct 25, 2026.

Heads up: some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes what we recommend. Learn more.

Bay Alarm MedicalMedical Guardian
Devices we track 5 3
Lowest monthly price $27.95/mo (Bay Alarm Medical SOS Home Landline) $27.95/mo (Medical Guardian MGHome Landline)
Lowest 3-year cost with fall detection $1006.20+ (Bay Alarm Medical SOS Home Landline) $1006.20+ (Medical Guardian MGHome Landline)
Device fee None to $199 Not stated
Fall detection Extra monthly add-on Extra monthly add-on
Works away from home Yes, on mobile devices Yes, on mobile devices
Smartwatch option Yes No
Month to month, no minimum term Yes Yes
Cancelling No activation fees or long-term contracts. Cancel anytime and unused months are refunded less shipping; a 15-day trial starts when the system arrives. No long-term contract and no activation fee; it issues pro-rated refunds for unused service, but a footnote says cancellation fees may apply.
See Bay Alarm Medical See Medical Guardian

A + means a fee isn't published, so the real total is higher. Shaded cells are lower. Want two specific devices? Compare any two.

Bay Alarm Medical devices

Bay Alarm Medical · Home and away

Bay Alarm Medical SOS All-In-One 2

A mobile button with GPS caregiver tracking

Billed monthly
$34.95/mosrc
Device fee
$149src
Fall detection
+$10/mosrc
  • GPS location

Cancelling: No activation fees or long-term contracts. Cancel anytime and unused months are refunded less shipping; a 15-day trial starts when the system arrives.src

View current priceChecked Oct 25, 2026

Bay Alarm Medical · At home

Bay Alarm Medical SOS Home Cellular

In-home coverage without a landline

Billed monthly
$34.95/mosrc
Device fee
Nonesrc
Fall detection
+$10/mosrc
  • Cellular, no landline needed

Cancelling: No activation fees or long-term contracts. Cancel anytime and unused months are refunded less shipping; a 15-day trial starts when the system arrives.src

View current priceChecked Oct 25, 2026

Bay Alarm Medical · At home

Bay Alarm Medical SOS Home Landline

In-home coverage over a landline

Billed monthly
$27.95/mosrc
Device fee
None
Fall detection
Extra; price not publishedsrc
  • Needs a landline

Cancelling: No activation fees or long-term contracts. Cancel anytime and unused months are refunded less shipping; a 15-day trial starts when the system arrives.src

View current priceChecked Oct 25, 2026

Bay Alarm Medical · Home and away

Bay Alarm Medical SOS Micro

A small wearable worn on the wrist, a lanyard or a belt clip

Billed monthly
$34.95/mosrc
Device fee
$149src
Fall detection
+$10/mosrc
  • GPS location

Cancelling: No activation fees or long-term contracts. Cancel anytime and unused months are refunded less shipping; a 15-day trial starts when the system arrives.src

View current priceChecked Oct 25, 2026

Bay Alarm Medical · Watch

Bay Alarm Medical SOS Smartwatch

A smartwatch alert

Billed monthly
$39.95/mosrc
Device fee
$199src
Fall detection
+$15/mosrc
  • GPS location

Cancelling: No activation fees or long-term contracts. Cancel anytime and unused months are refunded less shipping; a 15-day trial starts when the system arrives.src

View current priceChecked Oct 25, 2026

Medical Guardian devices

Medical Guardian · Home and away

Medical Guardian Guardian Flex

A wearable for a parent who goes out, worn on a necklace or belt clip

Billed monthly
$44.95/mosrc
Paid yearly
$39.95/mo ($479.40 a year)
Device fee
Not stated
Fall detection
Extra; price not publishedsrc
  • GPS location
  • Cellular, no landline needed

Cancelling: No long-term contract and no activation fee; it issues pro-rated refunds for unused service, but a footnote says cancellation fees may apply.sources differ

View current priceChecked Oct 25, 2026

Medical Guardian · At home

Medical Guardian MGHome Cellular

In-home coverage without a landline

Billed monthly
$38.95/mosrc
Paid yearly
$34.95/mo ($419.40 a year)
Device fee
Not stated
Fall detection
Extra; price not publishedsrc
  • Range up to 1,400 ft
  • 32-hour backup battery
  • Cellular, no landline needed

Cancelling: No long-term contract and no activation fee; it issues pro-rated refunds for unused service, but a footnote says cancellation fees may apply.sources differ

View current priceChecked Oct 25, 2026

Medical Guardian · At home

Medical Guardian MGHome Landline

In-home coverage over a landline

Billed monthly
$31.95/mosrc
Paid yearly
$27.95/mo ($335.40 a year)
Device fee
Not statedsources differ
Fall detection
Extra; price not publishedsrc
  • Range up to 1,400 ft
  • 32-hour backup battery
  • Needs a landline

Cancelling: No long-term contract and no activation fee; it issues pro-rated refunds for unused service, but a footnote says cancellation fees may apply.sources differ

View current priceChecked Oct 25, 2026

See our picks in the best medical alert systems, or rank every device by three-year cost.